Two Redbarn chews, two different jobs
Redbarn makes two popular all-natural dog chews that look similar at a glance but serve very different purposes. The Filled Bone is a beef femur bone stuffed with peanut butter filling, built for dogs that love to lick and gnaw. The Collagen Braid is a protein-rich, digestible chew made from beef collagen, shaped like a braid. Choosing between them comes down to your dog's chewing style, dietary sensitivities, and how long you need the chew to last.
Key facts at a glance
- Redbarn Filled Bone Natural Peanut Butter LRG: Redbarn Filled Bone Natural Peanut Butter LRG is an all-natural white beef femur bone hand-filled with a peanut butter filling through a proprietary process. The hand-filling process helps the filling stay semi-moist and adhere to the bone walls, so it stays on the bone instead of ending up on your carpet.
Redbarn Filled Bone Natural Peanut Butter LRG - Redbarn Collagen Braid 12 IN: Redbarn Collagen Braid 12 IN is 100% natural, free from grain, gluten, wheat, corn, and soy, and packed with 75% protein. This makes it a suitable option for dogs with common food sensitivities, and the high protein content supports a high-protein diet.
Redbarn Collagen Braid 12 IN
What each chew is made for
The Filled Bone is designed for dogs that enjoy a longer-lasting chewing session. The bone itself is oven-roasted for safety, and the peanut butter filling provides a tasty reward that keeps dogs engaged. It's recommended for light, moderate, and power chewers alike, making it a versatile choice for most dogs.
The Collagen Braid, on the other hand, is a digestible chew that's higher in protein and lower in fat than traditional rawhide. It's a good option for dogs that need a chew that's easier on the digestive system, and it also provides joint support through naturally occurring chondroitin and glucosamine.
Filled Bone vs Collagen Braid: which fits your dog?
Both chews are all-natural, but they differ in structure, digestibility, and how long they last. Here's a side-by-side look at the key differences.
- Chewing style: The Filled Bone suits dogs that like to lick and gnaw at a bone, while the Collagen Braid is better for dogs that prefer to chew and tear at a braided texture.
- Digestibility: The Collagen Braid digests much easier than traditional rawhide, making it a gentler option for sensitive stomachs. The Filled Bone is a natural bone, so it's not meant to be fully consumed.
- Longevity: The Filled Bone is designed to last longer, especially for power chewers. The Collagen Braid is a chew that will be consumed over time.
- Nutritional extras: The Collagen Braid is rich in chondroitin and glucosamine, which support joint health. The Filled Bone provides the natural benefits of chewing, like boredom relief and dental hygiene.
How to choose between them
If your dog is a power chewer who loves to work at a bone, the Redbarn Filled Bone Natural Peanut Butter LRG is a solid pick. The large size and durable bone structure are built for extended chewing sessions. Plus, once the filling is gone, you can refill the bone with your own peanut butter from the pantry.
If your dog has a sensitive stomach or you prefer a chew that's fully digestible, the Redbarn Collagen Braid 12 IN is the better choice. It's free from common allergens like grain, gluten, wheat, corn, and soy, and it provides joint-supporting nutrients. Just keep in mind that it won't last as long as a bone.
What the catalog doesn't tell you
The supplied information doesn't include specific feeding amounts, calorie counts, or exact chew times for either product. Always supervise your dog with any chew, and consult your veterinarian if you have concerns about your dog's chewing habits or dietary needs.
